On sale

Creamy Chicken Pot Pie

Sale price

Regular price $34.99
( / )

Comes in a 4 Pack

There’s nothing quite so comforting as creamy chicken pot pies, and ours are scratch-made using only the finest ingredients available. A hearty mix of roasted chicken and vegetables in a creamy, cheesy gravy, we top our classic chicken pot pie with a flaky, buttery puff pastry for a satisfying meal that will soothe your soul.

Only the finest ingredients

chicken thighs, butter, blended oil, carrots, peas, celery, yellow onion, flour, butter, salt, black pepper, chicken stock, milk, cheddar cheese, paprika, cayenne pepper, onion powder, garlic powder, dried thyme, dried oregano, rubbed sage, cumin, egg

Heating, eating & storing your creamy chicken pot pies

For a golden top, beat one egg with a splash of water then brush egg onto pastry top. Reheat your pies on a sheet tray lined with aluminum foil for approximately 45-60 minutes in a 375-degree oven. The interior temperature of your pies should reach 165 degrees. The interior will be hot, so please be careful when eating straight from the oven (as we’re often tempted to do).

Once reheated, we suggest eating immediately and pairing with a nice green salad dressed with Merlin’s Market Honey Citrus Vinaigrette.

We don’t recommend using a microwave to heat your Irish steak and mushroom pies as the pastry may lose quality and the tin is aluminum, which may cause problems to your microwave.

You can refrigerate your pies for up to 5 days or freeze for up to 6 months when properly covered.

Shipping and local pickup options

Buy creamy chicken pot pies online, and we’ll carefully ship your order right to your doorstep via overnight or 2-day shipping. When your order is on its way, we’ll send a tracking number so you can follow your tasty delivery to your home.

We take exceptional care to ensure your order arrives in perfect condition—shipping our perishable products on Mondays and Tuesdays to avoid holds en route and using dry ice and insulated liners handmade right here in the US.

As our perishable products ship at a flat rate, you’ll find it’s most cost-effective to fill your box. For example, 2-4 pasties and 4-6 pies. Don’t forget to include a sauce, dressing, or seasoning!

Want to reduce your environmental footprint? We’re excited to announce that a return-a-box option is coming soon.

Please note: We may encounter an occasional 1-2 day delay due to holidays, severe weather, and limitations on dry ice availability.

Have questions? Please contact us.

Are you in the Minneapolis - St. Paul metro area? You can also buy creamy chicken pot pies online for local pickup at Merlins Rest Pub.

What do people say about our British savory pies?

The food is so good it brings me back to all of the times I've spent visiting my British family. I have a ‘Ratatouille moment.’ The steak and Stilton pie, as well as the Cornish pasty are two of my favorites. Perfect flaky crust, flavorful fillings.


I want to order these on repeat, where is the subscription button? The meat pies are a life saver on nights I don't want to cook.

Tom - St. Louis, MO

We love our mystery pie nights! I will order a few of everything, pop them on a baking tray and when they are done my family simply chooses one. There is always excitement when someone gets the Indian samosa hand pie.

Danny - Burnsville, MN

I have been sending care packages to my daughter in college for the last year. Knowing that she is getting homestyle meals makes me a very happy mama.

Theresa - South Dakota